Wow… Still processing. This was… Ficlets gone crazy! I love it! It’s so GOOFBALL ! I adore. You get extra kudos for rhyming, something I can’t do intentionally and hate to do unintentionally.

LoA

After consulting wikipedia, I find that the contestant has a 2/3 chance of winning if he switches, instead of a 1/2 like we would assume. Mathematically, it is slightly better to switch. Personally, I would try to gauge the hosts’ tonality, and body language before deciding.