Nice! I love the self contanied stories on Ficlet. The image of keeping the teeth in the bags… creepy. :)

Cool story! The first paragraph made me think it would go in an entirely different direction.

yipes! someone go get her! and the narrator, needs some psychiatric help.

Yeah, this one really offers the creepiness effect after the twist.
I still can’t decide what’s worse, keeping the teeth in Ziploc bags, or keeping them stored in a file cabinet.

Does he plan on going back there, or is he just afraid of the monsters that will “come out” if the light is not left on?

Nice one, very creepy.

Chills down your spine type of thing. I agree with Elsha – someone get the narrator a psychiatrist.